In the field of science and technology it is often said that we are standing on the shoulders of giants. Knowledge is a gradual, cumulative pursuit. We rely on centuries of information, experiments, and failures of previous generations to achieve new feats. However, the science community has some rethinking to do when it is learnt that these “giants” are racists.
Racial prejudice has shaped every system we rely on today, and even our knowledge of the world and humanity has been shaped by prejudices. One would hope that systems known for their values of ethics, rigorous proofs, and removal of any biases be unaffected by racism. However, that is far from the truth. This article aims to discuss the dark history of medicine and biomedical sciences, with a focus on anti-Black medical violence.
While I initially planned to explore the topic of grave robberies, more conversations and research on this topic increased my awareness of medical racism as an overarching issue. I had the opportunity to chat with Dr. Laura Meek on anti-Black healthcare.
Dr. Meek is a medical anthropologist and an assistant professor of anthropology and interdisciplinary graduate studies at UBCO. She studies medical knowledge production and how health inequalities are produced through inequitable systems of knowledge production. Meek’s research is based in Eastern Africa, and she teaches about medical racism in North America as well.
There are many cases of medical knowledge being formed with racial prejudice. Unfortunately in today’s world, the perpetrators are still praised and celebrated for their contributions.
A leading example of this is Dr. James Marion Sims, who is regarded by many as the father of modern gynecology. Sims predominantly practiced in Alabama, where he opened a hospital on a plantation for enslaved people.1 It should be noted that treatment of the enslaved individuals was for continued exploitation and labor, not for their own wellbeing.
It was at this hospital that Sims gained an interest in treating fistulas, an abnormal opening between the bladder and vagina.2 Sims experimented on enslaved African American women, including three named victims: Anarcha, Lucy, and Betsey. The main ethical concern is that Sims chose to perform these surgeries without anesthesia. Patients like Anarcha were subjected to over 30 surgeries.
Sims' reasoning to not offer anesthesia was in part due to a myth that Black individuals have a higher pain tolerance. The idea stemmed from a belief that Black people have thicker skin or fewer nerve endings, all to justify brutal labor and pain. This myth affects our health system to this day, despite being proven false. Doctors who hold such beliefs make less accurate diagnoses, and Black individuals are still systematically undertreated for pain relative to white individuals.3
A statue of Sims which has honoured him since the 1890’s was removed from New York’s Central Park in 2018.4 A new monument honouring Anarcha, Lucy, and Betsey as the mothers of gynecology was built in Alabama in 2021.5 Dr. Meek highlights accountability needs to be held as Sims is still viewed in high regard.
“Sims is often mentioned in contemporary medical textbooks as the father of gynecology, but the names of the women whose bodies that knowledge was produced on are almost never mentioned.”
Many petitions have been started to remove Sims name from the Sims speculum, Sims uterine curette, and several other devices.6 There has not yet been an official name change, and devices are still referred to with Sims namesake by manufacturers, medical textbooks, and licensing exams. Dr. Meek reflects on the present legacy of Sims:
“[Sims] is just one historic example of medical violence on Black bodies that has led to a contemporary situation where Black communities are less trusting of medical authority and less trusting of public health directives.”
Histories of experiences like Anarcha, Lucy, and Betsey’s have contributed to a lack of trust in the medical system that persists today. A small study found that Black women have a strong desire to find a Black ob-gyn, as they fear or have had experience with stereotyping or not being heard by care providers.7 However, another hurdle faced by these women is difficulties finding a Black obstetrician-gynecologist (ob-gyn).
Stephanie Awotwi-Pratt, a 2024 UBCO graduate, researched Black Canadian women’s experience with reproductive healthcare. Through conducting one-on-one interviews with 25 women, she found themes that Black women anticipate some form of discrimination and providers consistently dismiss their pain.8
The interviews reflect a border disparity that Black women are three times more likely to die of pregnancy-related causes than white women, even when socioeconomic status is accounted for.9 This highlights that there are still deep systemic inequities that shape our healthcare system.
Outside of gynecology, there are countless examples of historical and contemporary racial prejudices in medicine. Certain cases include falsified medical research being marketed as fact, such as the spirometer.
The spirometer is a tool that measures one's lung capacity, and a common myth at the time was that Black individuals had a lower capacity. This was “researched” by Samuel Cartwright, a physician and slaveholder in the 1850s.10 Cartwright claimed that his studies found that Black individuals had a 20% lower lung capacity. He wrote that the blood “sent to the brain [...] liberates their minds when under the white man’s control”, declaring that under slavery, the Black individual would have more brain activity.7
U.S. President Thomas Jefferson further interpreted that since Black people had a lower lung capacity, they were “disabled in the act of inspiration” and that slavery helped keep them alive.10
The false research was further built on by Benjamin Gould, who conducted a large study to prove Cartwright’s work. It is important to note that Gould only considered race in his patients, and never accounted for age, height, or high-pollution working conditions.10
Other studies even noted that Asian individuals had a lower lung capacity. It should be noted that more recent work has found that racial assumptions for lung capacity have “no biological basis”.11 Not only did this false assumption promote slavery, it motivated countless missed diagnoses. Dr. Meek states:
“When these technologies were being deployed on Asian or Black individuals, it would often miss actual breathing problems like asthma or pulmonary fibrosis because the device expected their capacity to be lower in the first place.”
Cartwright and Gould false research became so embedded in medical knowledge many modern spirometers still ask patients to disclose their race before testing. It is only in recent years that any change from this assumption has been pursued. Until recently, many modern spirometers applied correction factors of 10 to 15% for Black individuals and 4 to 6% for Asian individuals.10
It was only in 2023, after a recommendation from the American Thoracic Society, that many labs removed the racial bias in the device. However, with thousands of labs using spirometers, the change is slow.12 Removal of racial bias increased the percentage of lung defect detections by over 20%, demonstrating the severity of missed diagnoses.11 The consequence of this is countless Black and Asian individuals not receiving diagnoses for breathing problems over nearly two centuries.
Another more contemporary example is the pulse oximeter, a device that is placed on a patient’s finger to measure pulse and oxygen levels. It does so by using light to measure the color of your blood. Blood saturated with oxygen is bright red, and drops to a cold, purple-red in the absence of oxygen.13
This device was developed on predominantly white skin, and researchers have found strong racial bias in its findings. Darker skin absorbs more light. For non-white individuals, the device tends to overestimate the amount of oxygen due to darker skin tones.13 Like the spirometer, this leads to missed diagnoses in Black and Asian patients. The Black Physicians of Canada have advocated for more awareness and action regarding the pulse oximeter.14
Sims’ work, the spirometer, and pulse oximeter are only a few examples in history. This leads to further mistrust in today’s medical system and negative health consequences, however it has another important effect on the lives of Black patients today.
The negative effect of chronic stress on health has been extensively studied. A hypothesis was proposed by Dr. Arline Geronimus stating that racism, microaggressions, and socioeconomic pressures put someone under daily stress.15 The result of this chronic stress weathers an individual’s physical stress, leading to poorer overall health. This is known as the weathering hypothesis.
So, how can we address the weathering and chronic stress, medical mistrust, and systemic racism that still permeates the healthcare world?
As demonstrated by Awotwi-Pratt, Black women tend to look for Black gynecologists. Other fields operate similarly, however it can be difficult for patients to find Black doctors. Black individuals tend to make up a smaller portion of the doctor population. For example, in Ontario, Black people make up 4.7% of the population but only 2.3% of the doctors.16
To address this, UBC’s Faculty of Medicine launched a Black student pathway into their medical school. The pathway requires an additional essay to be reviewed by Black Student MD Admissions Subcommittee, and also provides pre-admissions workshops, mentorship, and financial support.17 The subcommittee recommends that 14 seats (4.3%) annually be considered through the pathway.18
Providing support for Black doctors is a great start, and another avenue of support should be dedicated to Black researchers. In 2020, the U.S. National Institute of Health was composed of less than 3% of Black principal investigators.19
Overall, further research into racial biases can help identify inequalities, as they have for the spirometer and pulse oximeter. Spreading awareness on research and racial biases for medical practitioners, students, and the general public can break down false myths. Groups such as Canada’s Black Health Alliance and Black Physicians of Canada have been working towards breaking down such myths.
Dr. Meek also emphasizes the importance of recognizing overall systemic medical violence.
“Medical violence against Black communities is part of a wider phenomenon of colonial and racist violence in medicine. The experiences of Black communities are linked through that to the experiences of Indigenous communities. So to make a more equitable and fair healthcare system, we need to investigate all forms of prejudice and fight them together in a unified manner.”
Anti-Black medical violence is not confined to the past. Its consequences are widely felt by Black individuals today. However, as Dr. Meek notes, anti-Black violence is not isolated and is a part of a larger reality of racial prejudice. This includes systemic discrimination against Indigenous communities, people of color, and other marginalized groups. To move forward from racialized medical violence, we must first acknowledge and educate others, and make active steps to ensure that every individual’s voice is heard in the medical world.



